Zimbabwe is the new Pakistan?

Alec Muchadehama in his office, 19 August 2008

Alec Muchadehama in his office, 19 August 2008

Remember two years ago when then President Musharraf removed the Chief Justice of Pakistan’s Supreme Court, setting off howls of protest from the Pakistani legal community? Many people, including Musharraf, seemed surprised that lawyers had it in them to take to the streets and demand respect for the rule of law.  But if any of you have ever been to a “bar review” (read booze fest) hosted any given Thursday evening by one of our nation’s law schools, or been to a patent bar continuing legal education course (I’ve heard those patent lawyers get rowdy), you nodded your head wisely as the Pakistani lawyers protested continuously for two years until the Chief Justice was reinstated.

Until recently, lawyers in Zimbabwe, despite being one of the most active civil society groups in the country, had for the most part avoided being swept up in the political machinations and repression experienced in recent years.  In the last few months, though, this seems to be changing. In February, two lawyers were arrested while observing a Valentine’s Day protest in Harare.  Then in March, the magistrate who granted bail to arrested prospective Minister of Agriculture Roy Bennett was arrested.  Last week, respected human rights lawyer Alec Muchadehama was arrested in court for allegedly attempting to circumnavigate proper legal channels in securing the release of his clients on bail.  Now it was announced today that the two lawyers detained in February will go to trial on charges of “participating in a gathering with intent to promote public violence, breaches of the peace or bigotry.”

In response, lawyers and journalists promptly took to the streets in Harare today to protest government harassment.  Now, I’m not just saying this because I am a lawyer, but perhaps those pulling the strings in Zimbabwe might want to heed the lesson painfully learned by Musharraf, whose relatively rapid downfall is widely attributed to have commenced when he began messing around with lawyers.  To misappropriate Adam Sandler’s Zohan movie title, “You don’t mess with the lawyers.”

AIUSA welcomes a lively and courteous discussion that follow our Community Guidelines. Comments are not pre-screened before they post but AIUSA reserves the right to remove any comments violating our guidelines.

7 thoughts on “Zimbabwe is the new Pakistan?

  1. Lessons learned are, of course, for everyone…not just for those who pull the socio-politico-economic strings…especially those involved in corruption and "ruling" with tactics of brute force. They are the last ones who may truly "learn" anything.

    Lawyers collaborating with non-lawyers to become a force not to be "messed with" is what is needed. Moving outside the circle of lawyer-dom, and into the realities that don't involve the twisted interpretations that the "letter of the law" can bring. Yet, bringing a precise and well-presented protection lawyers can bring against corruption and brute force tactics of rulership.

    A couple links of interest related to Zimbabwe–

    Mapping violence in Zimbabwe elections http://www.sokwanele.com/map/electionviolence

    The "New Zimbabwe"? http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/us1.html

    Jason L.
    Executive Director, Earth Intelligence Network (501c3) http://www.earth-intelligence.net http://twitter.com/earthintelnet http://re-configure.org

  2. Lessons learned are, of course, for everyone…not just for those who pull the socio-politico-economic strings…especially those involved in corruption and "ruling" with tactics of brute force. They are the last ones who may truly "learn" anything.

    Lawyers collaborating with non-lawyers to become a force not to be "messed with" is what is needed. Moving outside the circle of lawyer-dom, and into the realities that don't involve the twisted interpretations that the "letter of the law" can bring. Yet, bringing a precise and well-presented protection lawyers can bring against corruption and brute force tactics of rulership.

    A couple links of interest related to Zimbabwe–

    Mapping violence in Zimbabwe elections http://www.sokwanele.com/map/electionviolence

    The "New Zimbabwe"? http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/us1.html

    Jason L.
    Executive Director, Earth Intelligence Network (501c3) http://www.earth-intelligence.net http://twitter.com/earthintelnet http://re-configure.org

  3. Lessons learned are, of course, for everyone…not just for those who pull the socio-politico-economic strings…especially those involved in corruption and "ruling" with tactics of brute force. They are the last ones who may truly "learn" anything.

    Lawyers collaborating with non-lawyers to become a force not to be "messed with" is what is needed. Moving outside the circle of lawyer-dom, and into the realities that don't involve the twisted interpretations that the "letter of the law" can bring. Yet, bringing a precise and well-presented protection lawyers can bring against corruption and brute force tactics of rulership.

    A couple links of interest related to Zimbabwe–

    Mapping violence in Zimbabwe elections http://www.sokwanele.com/map/electionviolence

    The "New Zimbabwe"? http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/us1.html

    Jason L.
    Executive Director, Earth Intelligence Network (501c3) http://www.earth-intelligence.net http://twitter.com/earthintelnet http://re-configure.org

  4. Lessons learned are, of course, for everyone…not just for those who pull the socio-politico-economic strings…especially those involved in corruption and “ruling” with tactics of brute force. They are the last ones who may truly “learn” anything.

    Lawyers collaborating with non-lawyers to become a force not to be “messed with” is what is needed. Moving outside the circle of lawyer-dom, and into the realities that don’t involve the twisted interpretations that the “letter of the law” can bring. Yet, bringing a precise and well-presented protection lawyers can bring against corruption and brute force tactics of rulership.

    A couple links of interest related to Zimbabwe–

    Mapping violence in Zimbabwe elections
    http://www.sokwanele.com/map/electionviolence

    The “New Zimbabwe”?
    http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/us1.html

    Jason L.
    Executive Director, Earth Intelligence Network (501c3)
    http://www.earth-intelligence.net
    http://twitter.com/earthintelnet
    http://re-configure.org

  5. This is not the First Time that the Independence of the Judiciary has been called into question. More often than not the Government has ignored any ruling that has not been in their Interest (Does anyone remember what happened to the Daily News?)

    So why is anyone suprised that the Lawyers for Adovocates are not being targeted by the Government.

  6. This is not the First Time that the Independence of the Judiciary has been called into question. More often than not the Government has ignored any ruling that has not been in their Interest (Does anyone remember what happened to the Daily News?)

    So why is anyone suprised that the Lawyers for Adovocates are not being targeted by the Government.

  7. Pingback: Zimbabwe’s Heroes | Human Rights Now - Amnesty International USA Blog